MBV - The Best In Indie Music and Culture


8:16 am

June 21st, 2008

Music Sucks Today Pt. DLXVI

[M]ore troubling even than the hypocrisy of a few rock stars is the narcissism at the heart of the phenomenon of home remixing–the notion that to take a work of creative expression and make it “ours” is to improve it. It is a colossal mistake to coerce an expression of others into an expression of ourselves. The premise of open-source remixing is that finally we can admire nobody so much as ourselves. But in music, as in all art and love and politics, there is usually more to gain in trying to understand what belongs, uniquely and idiosyncratically and serendipitously, to somebody else.

- David Hadju, “I Me Mine,” in TNR

One Response to “Music Sucks Today Pt. DLXVI”

  1. Links for 6.21.08: Girl Talk’s +/-, top albums of the last 25 years, exploring the Afronaut… « the listenerd Says:

    [...] *On the flip side: The New Republic brings the hate against such sampling: “It is a colossal mistake to coerce an expression of others into an expression of ourselves.” (For what it’s worth, this blog is nothing but a remix of my feedreader and e-mail inbox. Also, coercing the expression of others into the expression of ourselves is the basis of language.) [catbird seat] [...]

PREVIOUS ENTRY:Robert Pollard’s Boston Spaceships

NEXT ENTRY:Catbird Records New Release: Forest Fire – “Survival”


©2008 Catbird